The controversial English theologian Don Cupitt once suggested that the notion of ‘life’ has taken the place traditionally attributed to ‘God’ in our contemporary society. Instead of saying ‘thank God for giving me this or that’, Cupitt observes many are now in the habit of saying that ‘life has given me this or that’ or even that ‘life has given me many blessings’, just as God used to be designated as the giver of gifts and blessings in traditional religious lingo. When we are grateful for blessings or even for our existence, thankful for existing or being alive, expressing what we may call existential gratitude, the one we thank may no longer be ‘God’ but ‘life’ instead: many now just say that they ‘love life’ just as old religious folks used to say that they ‘love God’.[i]
According to Cupitt, although there is still a somewhat ‘religious’ character to the contemporary world’s ‘devotion’ to life, the replacement of God with life constitutes a kind of ‘secularization’: Once we believed in God, now we believe in ‘life’. The idea of secularization, at least as formulated or understood in this way, involves an emphasis on change: We used to believe in God, now we don’t. To say something is ‘secularized’ implies a progression from a religious state to a now non-religious or even anti-religious one.
The idea of change or progress over time is prevalent in common conceptions of the ‘secular’. Take for example the three definitions of ‘secularity’ given by Charles Taylor in his influential 2007 book A Secular Age: ‘secularity’ may refer to how religion and politics or church and state have become separate in modern society, how modern society has becomeless interested and involved in religious activities, or indeed how religious belief is no longer a default but has becomeone option among many in one’s way of navigating the contemporary world. There is a historical formulation of ‘secularization’ at work in all these ways of defining what Taylor calls ‘secularity’: We were not always secular; we just became so over time. We have become secular—or, more accurately, we have become secularized.[ii]
But is being ‘secularized’ the same as being ‘secular’?
Let’s reconsider the case of Cupitt’s account of ‘life’ and ‘God’ mentioned earlier. The understanding of life as something sacred need not be the result of some ‘secularization’ of religion or of the idea of ‘God’: one can easily imagine how traditional religion, especially a monotheism that speaks of God as ‘Life’ itself, can foster a sense of the sanctity of life without any process of secularization. Similarly, one may argue (as I do in my book Spiritual Life and Secular Thought, where I say more about the secular/secularized distinction[iii]) that the postulation of life as an object of spiritual devotion need not to be a secularized version of some religious devotion to God, but rather an outworking of secular—but not secularized—philosophical analyses of human experience and existence. Something can be ‘secular’ without being ‘secularized’.
Indeed, the word ‘secular’ did not always mean ‘secularized’. Rather, in its original meaning, the ‘secular’ or ‘secularity’ refers to clergy who did not belong to a religious order. The ‘secular’ were not ‘religious’ in the sense that they weren’t part of a monastic order or other forms of ‘religious’ life, but it did not mean that they did not hold religious or spiritual beliefs. The ‘secular’ simply designated a particular worldly way of life, whereby one lived in the world and not in some secluded monastery. The association of secularity with worldliness was not to distinguish the secular from religious practices (as we now understand the term ‘religious’ colloquially), but to distinguish them from the transcendent God who is not of this world. As Phil Zuckerman and John R. Shook put it in their introduction to The Oxford Handbook of Secularism:
“The origin of the word ‘secular’ is Latin: saeculum typically meant a fixed period of time, an age… The saeculum was not defined in contrast to any sacred concerns, and had a freestanding usage in Latin. In Christian Latin of medieval times, saeculum was a useful term for distinguishing this temporal age of the world from the eternal realm of God.”[iv]
To live in the saeculum – to live a secular life – is to exist ‘between times’: between creation and eschaton, between the beginning and end of the world as we know it.
Whereas God is eternal and unchanging, our world – our secular temporal realm – is full of flux and change. Indeed, if one adheres to a monotheistic doctrine of creation ex nihilo, one might also think that, unlike God who is ‘necessary being’, our world that is created out of nothing – one that need not exist but is somehow called into being by God – is radically contingent. To live an authentically secular life, one might say, is to attend to the ‘secular’ fact that we live in a temporal and indeed contingent world: that we do not exist self-sufficiently or eternally like God does; rather, we are dependent on structures and conditions that make our lives and existence possible. Instead of understanding our times or our world as ‘secularized’, recognizing the ‘secular’ character of our existence in a temporal, changing world is to recognize the kinds of beings which we are: finite, volatile, and indeed contingent.
To conflate the ‘secular’ with the ‘secularized’ is thus to not only misconstrue – to quite literally ‘secularize’(!) – the original meaning of the ‘secular’. It is, moreover, to project that which is ‘not secular’ or ‘pre-secular’ onto some historical past: to an idealised past that is (now) fixed and unchangeable, to another world that is ‘purely religious’ or even ‘sacred’, as though citizens of that world were somehow all in perfect communion with the eternal God. It is, to some degree, to mistake our contingent world – one that is in continuation with a ‘pre-secular(ized)’ past – with that which it is not: the eternal, perfect, unchanging life that properly belongs to God alone, who ‘does not change like shifting shadows’ (Jas 1:17).
To differentiate the ‘secular’ from the ‘secularized’ is of course not to deny that some secular things are indeed secularized. There is undoubtedly much critical power and insight in diagnosing (and critiquing) how various phenomena we encounter in our world are secularized versions of things from a more visibly ‘religious’ time. However, should one uncritically treat all things secular as ‘secularized’, always weighing them against some idealised ‘pre-secular(ized)’ counterfactual ‘religious’ world (or even some crypto-heavenly para-eternal realm), one may inadvertently come to overlook the goods we may find in our present world or indeed the good – or even gift – of life that we have been given.
It is only by recognizing one’s own existence as contingent – that one need not exist yet somehow does – that one can properly recognize one’s life as a gift and, in turn, be grateful for the life that one has been given—whether the giver or object of devotion to which one is grateful is named as God, ‘life’, or otherwise. In other words, to allude back to Cupitt’s observations, if one cannot recognize the contingency of one’s life, then one may not only be able to properly ‘love God’, one may not even be able to ‘love life’ either or be existentially grateful for one’s life or existence. There is no escape from our contingent – ‘secular’ – worldly existence. It is only by attending to our ‘secularity’ and recognizing the kind of finite contingent beings that we are that we can begin to properly appreciate the life that we are given, the world in which we find ourselves, and indeed ‘every good and perfect gift’ that we may receive and encounter in this life and in this world that we have between times.
[i] Don Cupitt The New Religion of Life in Everyday Speech (SCM Press) 1999.
[ii] Charles Taylor. A Secular Age (Harvard University Press) 2007.
[iii] King-Ho Leung. Spiritual Life and Secular Thought – A Phenomenology (Oxford University Press). 2026.
[iv] Phil Zuckerman and John R Shook (ed.). The Oxford Handbook of Secularism (Oxford University Press) 2017:4
Listen to the author explore this further in the podcast episode below:


