January 19, 2026

What even is a “religious” argument? Debating in a secular forum

Amongst the general cacophony surrounding Kim Leadbeater’s 2024 Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, there has been a consistent if predictable theme heard from some pro-assisted dying campaigners. Anyone familiar with the pre-history of this particular bill – such as Rob Marris’s Bill in 2015, Lord Joffe’s various attempts a decade earlier, or Lord Falconer’s relentless efforts to legalise assisted dying – will know that the general (if not universal) opposition to assisted dying expressed by religious actors – MPs, leaders and institutions – is a matter of particular vexation to campaigners. That being so, it is easier to undermine “religious arguments” as a class rather than to waste valuable campaigning time in answering each of the points they make and the charges they level.

Historically, there have been various ways of doing this. You can accuse religious arguments of being intellectually inadequate or disfiguring; the kind of “religion is based on antiquated faith rather than reason and so cannot be trusted with complex, modern matters like assisted dying” argument. If this fails, you can contend that religious arguments are, almost by definition, ill-suited to political debate because political debate demands compromise, and religions don’t have a very good reputation for doing that. Alternatively, you can make some general, sweeping statements about the nation being secular, thereby implying that religious arguments are somehow irrelevant or even inadmissible.

All three of these arguments have been on display in the British parliament during this particular debate. Religion “colours” people’s views, and prevents them from taking “an objective stance” in a debate that demands objectivity, Charlie Falconer claimed, in an attack on Shabana Mahmood.[1] Religion is based on “holy books” which are “ill-placed to help us resolve” complex modern debates, wrote Lewis Goodall in the Independent.[2] We shouldn’t be “imposing religious doctrine on a largely secular country”, argued Simon Jenkins in the Guardian.[3]

These are not, I think it’s fair to say, very sophisticated arguments and can be dealt with relatively easily, as I have recently tried to do in a Theos essay on religion and the assisted dying debate.[4] But what they reveal is a stubborn ignorance, willed or otherwise, about what a religious argument actually is.

More than 20 years ago, the political theorist Jeremy Waldron wrote that “secular theorists often assume that they know what a religious argument is like.” He explained how “they present it as a crude prescription from God, backed up with threat of hellfire, derived from general or particular revelation, and they contrast it with the elegant simplicity of a philosophical argument by Rawls (say) or Dworkin”. “With this image in mind,” he concluded, “they think it obvious that religious arguments should be excluded from public life.”[5]

His point is hyperbolic, but only just. A careful reading, not only of the critics in this debate but also of the “religious arguments” they target, reveals how little about the latter the former really understand and how, pace Waldron, the secular attacks are commonly made on straw men. The idea of a religious argument, so attacked by eager secularist critics, seems to be one that is clearly badged “religious”, easily identifiable by the way in which it quotes the Bible or the Qur’an, or cites dogma or infallible teaching, or invokes vaguely theological language like “the sanctity of life” or “playing God”. A religious argument looks religious.

This is why those arguments made by religious people and institutions (which therefore presumably are “religious arguments”) but which do not look religious in the way outlined above, have recently come in for criticism for being “dishonest”. Hence Esther Rantzen, who urged MPs “guided by their religious beliefs to be honest about why they will vote against the bill”. “What worries me,” she told LBC, was not the number of people who were “guided by their faith” to oppose the bill, but their lacking openness about it. “Some seem reluctant to declare that is the reason for their opposition to the bill,” she said. “Please be honest about your real motivation.”[6] If, so the logic goes, you expect a religious argument to be explicitly and transparently religious, and instead you hear from religious figures talk of changing attitudes to the vulnerable, or the need for better palliative care, or the risk of coercion, you naturally assume that these latter reasons are a kind of dissembling, a fundamental dishonesty which is masking genuine motivations.

But this is not how religious argumentation – or, as it happens, any serious, thought-through reasoning – actually works. What you might call ‘policy’ or ‘practical’ objections, such as concern for the vulnerable, fear of slippage, risk of suicide contagion, etc. – are not alternatives to deeper, underlying ‘principled’ objections, so much as outworkings of them.

So, for example, many people (religious and non-religious) expressed an anxiety, during the debate, that assisted dying legislation posed a particular risk to the elderly, lonely, and disabled. For the Christian parliamentarians and campaigners who did so, this view was a consequence of their conviction, grounded in the example and teaching of Christ and the lessons of scriptures, that God has a particular concern for (and so humans have a particular responsibility for) the “the poor, the widow, the alien, and the orphan”. It was not an alternative to it.

Religious participants in this debate did (and do) not face a choice between openly theological arguments (e.g. “Religion that God our Father accepts as pure and faultless is this: to look after orphans and widows in their distress”) and allegedly secular ones (e.g. “I oppose this bill because it fails to have sufficient safeguards against self-coercion among the aged”). Rather, they will view the latter as an articulation or demonstration of the former. Indeed, by this reckoning, allegedly “secular” arguments (like “this bill will adversely affect the vulnerable”) are not secular at all, but rather translations of theological motivations into “public reasoning”. And it is worth remembering that this is precisely what secular campaigners have long demanded: “don’t quote the Bible at me but talk in language I can understand”.

In reality, the actual process of “religious arguments” is more complex than this idea of “translation” into “public reasoning” suggests. The Theos report mentioned earlier poses four levels to any such argument, whereby (1) an underlying philosophy, worldview or conception of reality, informs (2) an understanding of the human person, which then shapes the attitude to and prioritisation of (3) key principles, which finally (4) steer the approach to the policy in question. According to this schema, a religious argument against assisted dying might work in the following way.

  1. I am a Christian. I believe that the love of God is foundational to existence, and that the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ reveal to us a God of compassion, who suffers with us and through his own suffering demonstrates that love is stronger than death.
  2. My underlying faith tells me that human persons are possessed of an inalienable dignity that is grounded in the love of God; that such dignity is fundamentally relational, and that we must work for lives that are characterised by care, love and compassion particularly among the most vulnerable. My underlying philosophy also strongly suggests to me that humans are sinful beings who often elevate their own good over others’, so I believe we should be cautious in legislating for practices that might be open to abuse.
  3. My understanding of the human person causes me to pay particular attention to the principles of ‘compassion’ and ‘dignity’ (understood as relationship rather than autonomy), as well as to ‘risk’ and ‘harm’. It tells me to reject any sense that humans are intrinsically a ‘burden’ on one another and to heed but not always obey the demands for ‘agency’ and ‘autonomy’.
  4. And so, on balance, my principles (allied to ample empirical evidence) cause me to oppose this bill, as I believe changing the law would pose a genuine risk that we will end up killing rather than caring for those who most need love and support.

This outline is over-schematised, not to mention idealised: human beings are rarely as rationally and carefully thought out as this; instinct, gut feeling, personal interest, and social pressure plays a much more substantial role in our thinking. Moreover, it only takes one line of argument; it is quite possible for someone to begin in the same way “I am a Christian” but end up with a different conclusion. For example (and more briefly):

  1. My Christian faith informs my views on the centrality of freedom (“it is for freedom that Christ has set us free”), the imperative of alleviating suffering, and the idea that death is not the end for human beings.
  2. That faith tells me that while each person is of infinite value but that doesn’t mean that every life must be preserved at all costs, and that “in the sure and certain hope of the resurrection”, we better honour the human person by respecting their agency in times of extreme suffering.
  3. This understanding of the human person causes me to place particular emphasis on principles of agency and autonomy, and, within strict restrictions, to choice.
  4. On balance, my principles cause me to support this bill, as long as its regulations hold.

Without labouring the point with another example, it is worth stress that this is exactly the same scheme – from philosophy, through person, to principle, and ultimately policy – that all serious arguments adopt, including non-religious ones. The idea that some only deploy, and only need to deploy, reason and evidence to settle a debate like the legalisation of assisted dying, as suggested by commentators like Simon Jenkins, is ridiculously naïve. Everyone has a worldview. There is no view from nowhere.

The key point in all this is less the precise steps and stages of the argument outlined above, and more the overarching point that the “religiousness” of this argument comes from its foundation or starting point – the underlying philosophy – rather than its final position or articulation of its conclusion. By way of analogy, identifying religious arguments might be compared to identifying a motor vehicle. All too often, those who criticise religious reasoning, do so on the assumption that the religious element in the reasoning works like the logo on the car. Either it’s badged “religious” or it’s not, and if it’s not, it’s either officially non-religious, or it is being dishonest. In reality, whether a line of reasoning is religious or not is more akin to whether the vehicle is a petrol, diesel, hybrid, or electric. The religiousness, or worldview, is what ultimately powers the argument rather that what it looks like. Recognising that would defuse the “dishonesty” accusations that were thrown about so carelessly and unhelpfully in this debate.

“How much have your religious views influenced your decision?”: religion and the assisted dying debate is available at www.theosthinktank.co.uk


References

[1] “Ministers speaking out against assisted dying ‘are giving false impression’, says peer” The Guardian, Eleni Courea, 24 November 2024, https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/nov/24/ministers-speaking-out-against-assisted-dying-false-impression-charlie-falconer.

[2] “MPs are being dishonest about why they oppose assisted dying” The i Paper, Lewis Goodall, 28 November 2024, https://inews.co.uk/opinion/mps-dishonest-oppose-assisted-dying-3405508.

[3] “It’s outrageous that religious faith is being brought into the assisted dying debate” The Guardian, Simon Jenkins, 25 November 2024, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/nov/25/assisted-dying-bill-vote-parliament-religious-faith.

[4] ““How much have your religious views influenced your decision?”: religion and the assisted dying debate”, Theos Think Tank, Nick Spencer, 12 June 2024, https://www.theosthinktank.co.uk/research/2025/06/24/how-much-have-your-religious-views-influenced-your-decision-religion-and-the-assisted-dying-debate.

[5] Quoted in Nigel Biggar, ‘‘‘God’ in Public Reason”, Studies in Christian Ethics 19, No. 1 (2006): 12, https://doi.org/10.1177/0953946806062266.

[6] “Rantzen urges MPs ‘to be honest’ about religious opposition to assisted dying” The Standard, Aine Fox, 27 November 2024, https://www.standard.co.uk/news/politics/shabana-mahmood-mps-esther-rantzen-wes-streeting-life-b1196734.html.


Photo Credits: Ozlem Ozdemir | Unsplash

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required